Annotated Bibliography

Research Question: In what ways does Oryx and Crake connect traditional gender with how they bleed into patterns of violence, consumer culture, and emotional detachment within late-capitalist culture

 

Annotated Bibliography:

 

Franks, Nadia-Terese Laguna. “‘Belief Rather Than a Memory’: The Relationship Between Gender and Trauma in Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and Crake.” C21 Literature, vol. 11, no. 1, 2024, p. Volume 11 • Issue 1 • 2024 • Spring-Summer 2024,

https://doi.org/10.16995/c21.8735.

 

In this article, Nadia-Terese Laguna explores how Margaret Atwood’s novel Oryx and Crake explores topics like traditional gender norms and trauma within a post 9/11 dystopia. She depicts the gender binary as a social construct that is a trauma driven tool used to reinforce patriarchal control while masking suffering both as an individual and a collective feeling. Her analysis reveals how late capitalism weaponized the gender binary to sustain a hierarchical power and fosters alienation and emotional numbness. Through the use of a male protagonist’s struggles with toxic masculinity and the commodification of femininity, she argues how gender roles enable acting out, violence, and ecological devastation that in turn fosters emotional detachment. Thus, this article is a great source that gives us a view into feminist trauma for understanding gender roles in connection with violence, consumption, and an emotional disconnect in a dystopian future. 

Martín, Javier. “Dystopia, Feminism and Phallogocentrism in Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and Crake.” Open Cultural Studies, vol. 3, no. 1, 2019, pp. 174–81,

https://doi.org/10.1515/culture-2019-0015

 

In this article, Javier Martin explores how Margart Atwood’s novel Oryx and Crake portrays a world where male dominant thinking and sexual control lead to the progress of dangerous scientific ideas and damage to our environment, showing a culture that is obsessed with putting a price on the human body and suppressing empathy among ourselves. Martin uses feminist theory and Derrida’s concept of phallogocentrism to argue that Atwood’s dystopia is a critique on male dominated systems of knowledge and power. In this novel men such as Crake are the embodiment of sexual objectification, using hyper-rational logic that leads to destruction, while women such as Oryx resisted these norms through showing a victimized point of view, creating a powerful space. This dynamic offers a theoretical framework that can be used to analyze gendered power structures and how they influence scientific ambition and ecological collapse within the novel.

 

Siemann, Catherine. “Science, Gender and History: The Fantastic in Mary Shelley and Margaret Atwood.” Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts, vol. 27, no. 1 (95), International Association for the Fantastic in the Arts, 2016, pp. 170–72.

 

This review by William Tringali on Science, Gender, and History analyzes traditional gender norm roles and how they confine women, linking such norms to violence, emotional detachment, and systemic control which are all themes especially present in Margaret Atwood’s other work The Handmaid’s Tale and in Oryx and Crake. These books’ connection to male driven scientific transgression within a late capitalist consumption culture shows how gendered violence and emotional estrangement sustain the dominant economic nature. Tringali’s work provides a valuable framework into understanding the culture and historical forces surrounding gendered experience in such dystopian narratives. 

 

Ismael, Henir, and Hasan Saleh. “The discursive strategies of power and female resistance in Margaret Atwood’s the handmaid’s tale: a foucauldian reading.” Govara zanistîn mirovayeti ya-Zankoya Zaxo, vol. 11, no. 3, 2023, pp. 555–61, https://doi.org/10.26436/hjuoz.2023.11.3.1096.

 

This article explores how Atwood exposes how within traditional gender norms there is violence embedded that shows how women’s bodies have become tools used for political control and economic value. The author argues that the novel reveals how systems of power use elements like discipline, surveillance, and sexual regulation to enforce ideas such as female objectification and emotional detachment. Even though the main focus on this article is in Atwood’s other work The Handmaid’s Tale, it can still be used to support the research question since it demonstrates how Atwood constantly links patriarchal gender expectations to the theme of the commodification of bodies and the suppression of empathy within the late capitalist structure.

 

Kaličanin, Milena M., and Marija Nešić. “THE KATABASIS TROPE AND A DESCENT INTO FUTURE IN MARGARET ATWOOD’S THE HANDMAID’S TALE.” Društvene i Humanističke Studije (Online), vol. XXIV, no. 24, 2023, pp. 279–94.

 

This article looks into The Handmaid’s Tale, showing how Atwood uses a katabasis structure to expose violence produced by patriarchal gender norms. The author argues that that having such a strict control over women’s bodies, reproduction, and identity reflect an extreme extension of late-capitalist consumption where women have become a resource to be used rather than separate individuals to be cared for. This descent structure is used to underscore the psychological and political oppression of women while also revealing other paths to renewal or even resistance. Yet again, even though it’s not directly related to Oryx and Crake, this article still contributes to the historical view of how gendered suffering and dystopian futures interact in works made by Atwood. 

 

I changed my research question since i didn’t like the other one. I want to thank you again for giving me an extension. I went to the doctor and it got SLIGHTLY better, but then i got worse and now I’m sick in bed again. I have medicine now and I hope this goes away soon. 🙁

Simple Biography

Franks, Nadia-Terese Laguna. “‘Belief Rather Than a Memory’: The Relationship Between

Gender and Trauma in Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and Crake.” C21 Literature, vol. 11, no.

1, 2024, p. Volume 11 • Issue 1 • 2024 • Spring-Summer 2024,

https://doi.org/10.16995/c21.8735.

 

Xinzhu, Zhu. “The Ethics of Technology: Reflection on Gendered Science in Oryx and Crake.”

Forum for World Literature Studies, vol. 14, no. 5SI, 2022, p. 793.

 

Bergthaller, Hannes. “Housebreaking the Human Animal: Humanism and the Problem of

Sustainability in Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and Crake and The Year of the Flood.” English

Studies, vol. 91, no. 7, 2010, pp. 728–43,

https://doi.org/10.1080/0013838X.2010.518042

 

Martín, Javier. “Dystopia, Feminism and Phallogocentrism in Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and

Crake.” Open Cultural Studies, vol. 3, no. 1, 2019, pp. 174–81,

https://doi.org/10.1515/culture-2019-0015

 

Siemann, Catherine. “Science, Gender and History: The Fantastic in Mary Shelley and Margaret

Atwood.” Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts, vol. 27, no. 1 (95), International Association

for the Fantastic in the Arts, 2016, pp. 170–72.

 

I mostly used Hunter One Search to find the sources for my research question mainly because on everything else I looked on I couldn’t find anything. I don’t even really think the sources I found are going to be that useful for my research paper, so I may just entirely change my question since I’m having a difficult time finding anything to use as evidence. I used key words like masculinity and suppression but I got nothing from those so I had to go more broad and use the word gender which gave me a majority of the sources in the bibliography. I only really skimmed the abstracts so I’m not sure they’re even really all that good.

The Weight of Care

Chapter 2 of Weather by Jenny Offill the fragmented narrative continues on to show Lizzie’s life and her thoughts, but in this chapter mixed in with these fragmented thoughts is the recurring theme and focus on motherhood, whether that be Lizzie’s own journey with motherhood or Catherine’s journey as a new mother. Offill uses these small moments to show how Lizzie cares for others, whether that be her children, partner, or her family, come to shape her sense of self. This chapter shows how during moments of ecological distress the structure of a woman’s daily experience can become strained due to the emotional labor of having to care for those around you while standing strong through everything, an unmoving presence people can rely on.

This chapter often brings us back to Catherine and how her pregnancy is progressing as well as how it is affecting those around her, namely Henry, Lizzie’s brother. She is monitoring her brother and his road to recovery, checking in with him constantly and remaining vigilant for any signs that he may be relapsing. With her brother she is still caring for him even when he is a fully grown adult now. When they go out to dinner he expects her to pay and she does even if he is making a stable income now. Her struggles with her family are coexisting with her worries over the planet and environmental catastrophes that are occurring and she is aware of, putting her in intense emotional labor as she has to juggle the both of them. She is attempting to hold her family together by herself while the world around her continues to fall into disarray.

In coexistence with helping her brother she also has to help Catherine, her brother’s wife who recently got married to him and is pregnant. Lizzie is already a mother so she is able to help Catherine in her new journey of being a mother, helping her when she is pregnant since she is now family. She is there for Catherine to talk with her through her worries or just be there as a friend, she helps get her food and other stuff she may need, all without expecting or getting anything in return. When Catherine is close to giving birth she dispels her worries, saying this will all be over soon (Offill, 95). She helps her without a second thought even when her own mental state isn’t the most stable and she has a lot of issues of her own. No matter who it is or what Lizzie is going through if someone needs help, she helps to the best of her ability. 

Ultimately, Offill shows both the burden and necessity of this emotional labor. Lizzie finds meaning in her life in helping others but at the same time this is constantly leaving her little time to process her own emotions and take care of her own needs. Chapter 2 argues that motherhood and the emotional labor that comes with it shape much of how people move through their everyday lives.

Blog Post 5 – Life in Pieces

The opening chapter of Weather by Jenny Offill is filled with a bunch of fragmented narratives that can make the story hard to follow from the beginning. It is filled with short disconnected paragraphs, some that are only a sentence long, moving very quickly between different moments and thoughts of Lizzie. This fractured sort of story mirrors the fractured state of life while living in the Anthropocene. Through this Offill captures how an individual just going through the motions of life may try to make sense of a global crisis such as this while being limited by everyday language and thought.

Each fragment shown in the first part of this novel is fluctuating between Lizzie’s life with her family, her thoughts or feelings, and the work she does for her bosses podcast answering climate related questions. With no clear transition between subjects it can be quite jarring for some readers to grasp what’s even going on. This abrupt shift between familiar grounds to the unknown creates unease as it would for most people showing how in a matter of seconds our everyday lives can lean towards catastrophe. The reader is here to experience the jolting life of Lizzie where when one thing stops another immediately starts, mirroring how people today may be going about life with constant news and warnings about where our planet is headed, enrooting fear of our future.

The Anthropocene is also marked as a time where humans and nature are disconnected when that shouldn’t be the case. In this same manner we have disconnected our daily lives to the consequences we are having globally. This form of abrupt shifting in paragraphs embodies this sort of disconnection. The constant shifting mimics the short attention span we as people have nowadays where people are still just trying to go about their daily lives even with the knowledge that the planet is changing in irreversible ways. We skip from topic to topic and don’t often linger for too long. Sure the common person may try to put in their contribution at some point to try and save the planet but it will often quickly be snuffed out by something else that came along in their lives that is prioritized. This fragmentation of paragraphs in the novel suggests how impossible it is to form a single story regarding climate change. Instead Offill shows how we experience the Anthropocene through small moments in our life even if we may not realize. 

By structuring Weather in fragments Offill is showing the psychological effects it has on us. She does not give a solution in this first chapter to the crisis of the Anthropocene but rather shows to us what it is like to be living in these moments and in this time. This gives a strong message that even if coherence is lost we can still find meaning in these small fragments of our lives.